Charlotte Shane. For centuries, institutions, social leaders and ordinary civilians alike have decried the fundamental immorality and socially destructive capacity of pornography, prostitution and everything in between. Banyard is adept in the urgent, enraged, self-righteous rhetoric that this position inspires, and her vehemence has a certain intoxicating momentum.
But as was true for so many before her, the message is mired in logical fallacies and light on evidence. Nor does she recognise how regularly her complaints could be applied to other professions. She admits that female strippers, porn stars and escorts enter these professions because they need money.
So where would they be in a world in which sex work had been eliminated? Banyard speaks to a handful of former porn actors and strippers, but never explains why the voices of working women are absent. Banyard could have allowed interviewees to speak anonymously. She quotes law-enforcement officials at length, and downplays the prevalence of police rape, and the abuse of criminalised sex workers around the world. When it comes to fellow anti-prostitution activists, anyone with the right opinion is quoted as an authority. In an unforeseeable twist, the study determined many participants had encountered abuse and wished to find new jobs.
If Banyard had given any one of these organisations the same credence she gives Constabel, or perhaps had a real dialogue with them instead of in her own head, Pimp State would be a very different book. James Forsyth. Mary Wakefield. Liam Halligan. Rod Liddle. Katy Balls. Robert Peston.
Find Prostitution Sermons and Illustrations. Free Access to Sermons on Prostitution, Church Sermons, Illustrations on Prostitution, and PowerPoints for. Jesus said, “You search the Scriptures because you think that in them you have eternal life; and it is they that bear witness about me ”. When Jesus used this .
Matt Kilcoyne. Ross Clark. Jack Clover. Ian Acheson. Julie Bindel.
Anjali Joseph. Ellah Allfrey. Justin Cartwright. Police, under the Contagious Diseases Acts CD Acts , were rounding up prostitutes or suspected prostitutes and making them sign a register forever publicly linking them to that work. This made leaving prostitution almost impossible. Even worse, they were forced to endure regular painful internal examinations and treatments. Those found infected with a sexually transmitted disease were jailed until they were deemed cured.
The women shared horrific stories with Butler of brutal examinations that they felt were far more crushing than their sex work. Treatments were often excruciating and of uncertain value.
Butler recognized that the CD Acts violated the constitution of England and treated women unequally, since men who used prostitutes would never be treated in the same way. Her long campaign to repeal the CD Acts began. When Parliament argued to keep the CD Acts, it became clear how prostitutes were viewed by the majority of politicians. Butler was convinced this double standard was evil and would later speak at universities, directly appealing to young men to consider a different course.
As she talked to prostitutes and visited brothels, she uncovered even more heinous abuse. She was shocked at how young many prostitutes were and alarmed when she found out that some had been forced into prostitution. The age of consent at the time was 13, and there were no laws to protect young women from being lured away to other countries under false pretenses, only to find themselves enslaved in a brothel.
When arguing about raising the age of consent to 16, members of parliament MPs asked their fellow lawmakers to consider their past actions and the possible future actions of their sons before criminalizing having sex with young girls. Butler boldly spoke against such attitudes, calling out conservative MPs to face their hypocrisy. She was fearless in her criticism.
Butler felt called by God to be a voice of change. She knew if Jesus was on her side that was all she needed. She would speak to crowds, meet with political leaders, church leaders, and society ladies. She helped found associations to repeal the CD Acts and would later help found an international association. She wrote pamphlets, using emotional appeals through retelling horrible stories of injustice or using cool logic to refute arguments against her.
She would spend hours every day writing letters to friends and supporters, as well as those who still needed to be convinced of the worth of the cause.
Get Books by Jeremy Myers. Summer Sermon Series. Her fingerprints are to be found all over the social change that happened during her lifetime. In order to have a prostitute…there must be a willing man…. The prostitution and drug sales that happened from her house came to an end.
England was basing its decisions on other countries who were controlling prostitutes through government programs. To challenge England, she needed to better understand what was happening elsewhere. Here she would only find more suffering.
She would visit brothels where women and many young girls were kept locked up in dirty rooms, hardly ever seeing sunlight. In Geneva, she saw prostitutes who were not only living in an earthly hell but were told that they must not be of the elect and so were destined for an eternal hell. Butler saw young children in cages who would eventually be given to brothel owners to use.
She was escorted through a brothel in Paris that housed an estimated children between the ages of 5 and 11—an experience so traumatizing that she would write that she dared not recall the horrors she had glimpsed.
Despite the hardship of uncovering so much torment, Butler did obtain the salient information she needed. She was able to further fight the CD Acts in England, as well as spark international attention, by exposing the ineffectiveness of government programs in controlling sexually transmitted disease. She would point to the many abuses of women happening under the legal care of the state, how life expectancy for prostitutes was short, with children often living only two years once in a brothel.
As she further honed her arguments, she was able to continue to gather support for repealing the CD Acts.
In the end, her influence was vast; the CD Acts were finally repealed, the age of consent was raised to 16, and laws were put into place to protect English girls from being kidnapped into prostitution. Her fingerprints are to be found all over the social change that happened during her lifetime. Butler accepted this fate because she never sought fame for herself. While she accomplished much with her life, there is still work to be done, and a new generation of advocates are rising up to take up the cause.
I am in earnest … and I will be heard. Kimi Harris writes at kimiharris. They live in the beautiful Northwest with their three girls and a cat. Make the Church more beautiful. Sections Home. Prayer Abortion Fatherhood. Subscribe Subscriber Benefits Give a Gift.
Subscribers receive full access to the archives.